Introduction

Roguelike Games: ADOM

The ADOM Background


History in Motion

The Past

The Present

The Future

Version History

The Diary


Bugs

Show Open Bugs

Show Fixed Bugs

Show Open RFEs

Show Closed RFEs

Search for a Bug

Submit a Bug Report

OS Blues


Support

Archive

Download

Links

The FAQ

rec.games.roguelike.adom


Media Coverage

Read This!

ADOM in the Spotlight


Miscellaneous

Licensing ADOM

The Postcard Quest

readme.1st

Voting

The Myth of Creation

The Gallery


Air Water

© Copyright 1994-2018 by Thomas Biskup. All Rights Reserved.

Fire

"Some gems harbour magical powers."
(Fortune Cookie of the Day)

Return to ADOM Central | Return to the index page
Earth

Bug #4980
Bug synopsis: 'w'alk key should work while Sick
Reported against: ADOM 1.1.1
Operating system: Windows XP
Submitted on: 2003-12-26, 14:26:42
Submitted by: Sam Blanning
Bug state: in progress
Bug description: Currently the game refuses to let you 'w'alk while Sick. This was sensible before v1.0.0, since Sickness took off 1-2HP every turn and a PC that attempted to 'w'alk would probably end up dead.

Now (since v1.0.0), however, Sickness is more of a long-term annoyance, like Muted, than a short-term threat like Poisoned - it effectively temporarily reduces your stats and halves your HP. So not being able to use the 'w'alk key doesn't make any sense, especially considering how long Sickness lasts if you don't cure it. Not being able to use the 'w'alk key actually makes things more dangerous, since it encourages players to just hold the key down, particularly while resting.

Naturally the PC should still be interrupted while 'w'alking if he has a feverish fit, but otherwise he should be able to 'w'alk as normal while sick.

This idea was floated on RGRA and received 4 positive responses and no negative responses. One poster (sqweek) also suggested that the same should be applied to poison - being able to walk but interrupting the PC when poison causes damange.
Bug evaluation: No evaluation so far.
Comments (4288): maybe the unability to walk automatically is *meant* to be an extra annoyance for the player?

-- Garand (2004-12-08, 15:04:49)
This is a duplicate of bug report #1978 (status: closed, will not be fixed).

The evaluation reads: "This will no[t] be changed. Sickness in any case reduces your hitpoints and thus is dangerous."

-- Matti Merikari (2004-12-09, 15:04:22)
Yeah, I support it completely.
As for the poison, I think it should be left as is - more feeling.

-- Solar Scorch (2004-12-12, 01:44:47)
QUOTE: The evaluation reads: "This will no[t] be changed. Sickness in any case reduces your hitpoints and thus is dangerous."

Isn't the idea behind the 'w'alk mode that you continue moving/resting until conditions change (like reaching a branch in a tunnel or entering a room from a tunnel) or, more relevantly, a threat is encountered?

Independently, sickness will not kill the PC. A PC at full health that becomes afflicted with sickness will not suffer from feverish fits unless their HP is over 50%. This creates a sort of equilibrium system, where natural HP regeneration of the PC slowly regains the PC's HP, but the sickness will cause a fit that brings it at or below 50% again. As long as no other dangers are present, this is a survivable status even without countermeasures.

This is essentially the same as walking around with half HP and no HP regeneration beyond 50%, which means that 'w'alking does NOT pose a threat to the PC. In fact, not enabling walk for players who are used to it encourages the dangerous behaviour of holding down the "wait for a turn" key, which will not pause for monsters or other dangers.

Compare the effects of poison to sickness. Both disable the 'w'alk command. Poison is a direct threat to a PC because one unnecessary move with low HP could spontaneously mean death. Sickness, on the other hand, will never cause a feverish fit if the PC's HP is below 50%. Sickness is sustainable should it lasts indefinitely. Poison will kill should it last indefinitely.

'w'alk is provided as a convenient substitute for repeatedly pressing directions when the direction is obvious. It transfers control to the player if a threat is encountered. Poison poses a threat because it can kill independently.

BUT SICKNESS DOES NOT POSE A THREAT, BECAUSE IT WILL NEVER KILL INDEPENDENTLY.

That's the bottom-line argument for pro-'w'alk-while-sick supporters.

-- Tung Nguyen (2004-12-17, 16:07:38)
I think this is a VERY good idea. I have fumed over this many times. it slows down the entire game, whenever you get sick. I don't think its a good idea for poison though.

-- Erik The Fighter (2004-12-22, 20:18:38)
You SHOULD be able to 'w'alk while sick. The inability to do so is simply annoying, nothing beyond that.

-- PORCO (2005-01-19, 18:01:27)
The inability to do so was logical in previous versions of ADOM (sickness was a potentially lethal condition, thus the inability to walk continuously was to prevent the player from foolishly dying in a long corridor and indicate that he needed to eat/drink a suitable cure first). Now, this feature (or rather the lack of it) is but a leftover from the earlier versions of the game.

-- PORCO (2005-03-21, 17:30:34)
I'd also have to say that not being able to walk while Sick really gets on my nerves as well. It's not life threatening by any reckoning, and since you stop walking when a monster rolls around, there's no danger from being "surprised" while sick either.

Even with 50% HP, a low-level player can still tackle a monster or three easily. I'd rather not waste my precious gaming time getting out of the dungeon by having to tap the movement keys over and over again... =)

Walking while poisoned, at least until you get the poison coursing through, also makes perfect sense to me. If you stop when the poison injures you, it's not dangerous -- you'll have an opportunity to pause long enough to drink a healing potion or two after your HP drops to critical levels.

-- Jeremy Gibson (2005-03-27, 03:17:59)
Just as an FYI, sickness can kill a low level character, because the amount of HP the character has might be too little so when the final wave of sickness comes you can die.

-- jonas (2005-04-17, 00:49:55)

-- Note from Thomas Biskup: One or more comments for this report have been banned because they contain HTML code and this website recently has been spammed by idiots trying to swamp the website with advertisements.


I'll vote for this RFE. I agree that sickness is no longer enough of an immediate threat to the player to warrant such interference... at least make it an available option in the adom.cfg file.

-- Benjamin Keller (2005-07-19, 22:58:28)
WTFis up with that blackjack spam?

-- A random pile of slime (2005-07-26, 02:47:23)
U damn big fucker idiot.

-- Battle bunny (2005-07-28, 14:51:35)
DAMN POKER SPAM!!! FU

-- asdsdafasdffdasa (2005-08-08, 23:30:47)
7mXjFlfGYqZ 2DczQ0kfxZq zD71HebGP6Zf

-- 9NRcCGPlTr (2006-02-22, 18:40:20)
JHYGKZd9R55d jlRDfpGHjbupY0 AiD42hOLSF

-- NayheCw1dA (2006-03-06, 14:24:03)
oliwudkxc ehfgqxu cuxky cfhvmodye xlhqzbkag yobfj tvol

-- bcjuv@mail.com (2006-11-18, 17:02:14)
prayg gyvxkn sygp raspid vgjml ixrpvhuq plhenbxa

-- tmup@mail.com (2008-05-02, 00:46:39)
<< Previous bugNext bug >>



The Design of Everyday Things Thomas Biskup recommends: The Design of Everyday Things
"I really believe that most software engineers think too little about the usability of their products. This book provides indepth thoughts on how to design usable items (not necessarily software) and how not to design usable tools. Many issues are adressed and the author shows a profound knowledge of the topics at hand (which is to be expected since he is teaching design for... many years). His writing is concise, yet humourous, which is a definite plus in my opinion. Every software engineer worth his money should be required to read this book! "

More details about this item can be found here: United States, United Kingdom, Canada, Germany.

In Association with Amazon Please support this website by going to Amazon through one of the links on this website (if you want to shop at Amazon at all that is ;-). It doesn't cost you any surcharge, but provides me with ADOM-related income. Thanks!

A complete list of my reading recommendations is available here.

Submit your own comment:

Please note:

  • Your comment will be publicly visible after a period of 7 days has passed.
  • The "comment" feature is not meant to degenerate into a kind of news system. It will be shut down once again (and probably forever) if people once more start abusing it. The idea behind the "comment" feature is to provide Thomas Biskup with helpful comments about how well RFEs are received and about how bugs might be fixed and nothing else!

Your name:


| Suggestions? EMail me.