I've just tested this by piling a bunch of headgear, armour, shields, footwear and melee weapons together, and I can use '+' and '-' to scroll up and down the list of items (it spans more than a single page), and everything is listed fine.
The obvious difference is that I don't have any potions in the mix.
When I then add a potion to that same pile, I scroll to the bottom of the list, and as Baranor reported only the heading for Potions is visible, the potion itself is not in the list.
And as expected, once I pick up just enough items for everything remaining in the pile (including the potion) to fit on a single page, the potion is listed at the bottom.