meh, there's been some serious dispute about your previous report and I need some clarification. Silfir and Soirana are copied into this discussion too. You said in your report:
Originally Posted by
meh
23345 After killing plenty of spiders, a dark elf priestess appears. Time to retreat.
23413 Ran into a frost giant. Went past it and locked the door behind.
However you did not specify where the priestess was or where you left the monster. Also didn't specify where she had summoned on the level. It seemed clear from watching your turn that you knew where the priestess was (in the stairs room) and how to approach. The others didn't have such an advantage - riktikticheck died because he tried teleporting onto the stairs and got surrounded by spiders on a different part of the level instead. With a more clear report that wouldn't have happened.
So, I'm a bit concerned that you have won through unfair means, and have violated the rules even (which state that you must give report in full details and not gain advantage from your own knowledge of the situation). Thus I need to ask a few serious questions:
1. Did you know the priestess' location?
2. Did you know she had summoned spiders around the stairs?
3. Did you yourself lead her into that room?
4. Did you know the giant was in the room too?
The rest of your actions I have no problem with - ring of doom plan was ingenious I must say. However not telling others about the position of an important group of monsters is against the rules, and has been brought up several times already in the games. I'd like to hear what you have to say on the matter before making any decision, and will likely bring up some discussion on the forums too.
Silfir and Soirana, if you have anything further to say on this I'd appreciate hearing your points of view as well.
Regards,
Darren Grey